Monday, October 20, 2003
Front Page
News
Op-Eds
Features
Literary
Lighter Side
Letters
About Us
About Romblon
Search
Previous Issues
Links

Join Romblon List
Message Board

Advertise with Us
Contact Us
Feedback

Classified Ads

Brain Drain or Brain Deluge/Surplus
By Eddie AAA Calderon, PhD


I am just new to the Romblon Yahoo group Mailing List, but one of the very interesting topics that have surfaced is the brain drain or brain deluge issue. I can't name all of the writers in the list group who have eloquently expounded on this subject matter whether their ideas do not necessarily agree 100% with others. And to name some will be grossly unfair.

Brain drain has been an old predicament that has either plagued or graced our country.

Brain drain shows that we have a lot of intellectual elite members in our country that have chosen to emigrate to other countries to find themselves a nice place in the sun and consequently to assist the countries' pursuit for economic and technological development. This may initially show that we are draining our elite to the detriment of our country, and that our institutions of higher learning may appear to have been non-stop in the production of such intellectual groups of people with an ironical twist. In doing so, and the fact that many chose to leave the country, may indicate a sad commentary that our educational insitutions are not able to be rewarded with their efforts and to place those graduates for the betterment of the Philippines.

I have previously compared this state of affair to a woman giving birth to a child only to put him/her up for adoption because she and her family are unable to provide for when the child grows up.

Of course we can't lay the blame on those who chose to emigrate. Many of our e-mailers have correctly and logically countered that unless our country and business institutions can provide them with commensurate employment, they have the right to seek for their own pursuit of happiness.

One eminent member of our group, and we can call him a venerable member not only because of his age but his intellectual acumen despite his age, avers that it is not brain drain but brain deluge. This may show a definite contradiction in analysing our situation, but after laboriously pondering on this, I found out that brain drain and brain surplus (my substitute term for brain deluge) are indeed complimentary and therefore not necessarily contradictory.

The fact that we are producing continuously our intellectual group shows that we have brain surplus. And it is this surplus which enable our country to export our brain power to many countries, especially Western countries, who are looking for it. The emigration phenomenom does not drain our intellectual community but they continue to fill the void caused by the drainage as the graduates move to other countries.

This in itself gets the schools busy and therefore makes them stay in business which have become more lucrative over the years. The appearance of brain drain as the graduates found new place in the sun in foreign countries do not really drain our economy as they remit lots of money back to the country in terms of their support for their loved ones and friends. As one e-mail member eloquently states, we live not only in a local but a global economy: Ergo and in quoting her, "why let your talent and skills not be fully exploited for mankind. I assume that there are not enough job openings in the Philippines to make full use of ...(our peoples' technological) training."

But sending money is not the only means to contribute back to the Philippines economically speaking. We do have lots of Kababayans who visit the country to do various types of volunteer work which are very much needed. We also have those who send books to our institutions of learnings and to their families. We also have Kababayans who retire or have retired in the Philippines from abroad and therefore using their much valued or appreciated foreign currencies to spend their money and live comfortably in the Philippines.

In short, if we speak of the movement our intellectual members to other countries and the beneficial results to our country in terms of remittance and others, the concept of brain drain is not necessarily a contradiction of brain surplus. We may not even even want to use these terms anymore. Even if we want to continue using them, their impact to our country is again very beneficial. The emigration exodus has then graced and uplifted our country and not a downgrade.

 


The author is a retired assistant professor of international politics at Bernidji State University in Minnesota. He now works as a coordinator for MInneapolis Department of Civil Rights. Originally from Kamuning, Quezon City, life just got lovelier many times over with his recent marriage to Naziyat, his "Mutya" from Kyrgyzstan.